my grade
-/5

average
3.66/5

Shanghai Grand

number of reviews: 0number of reviews: 0number of reviews: 1number of reviews: 0number of reviews: 1number of reviews: 2number of reviews: 7number of reviews: 13number of reviews: 21number of reviews: 6

Cinemasie's opinions

6 reviews: 3.71/5

your opinions

45 reviews: 3.77/5



Archibald 3.75 The encounter of two actors who radiate on screen in this very good mob saga in...
François 3.5
Junta 4
Ordell Robbie 3
jeffy 4
Anel 4
order by grades | date | reviewer    lengths: any length medium and long only long only


The encounter of two actors who radiate on screen in this very good mob saga in 30's Shanghai

Two monsters of HK cinema : Leslie Cheung & Andy LauShanghai Grand, it's the encounter of three monsters of hong-kongese 7th art : Leslie Cheung Kwok-Wing and Tsui Hark at the production (meaning discrete direction...). In this movie, you can feel a whole latent nostalgia of the hong-kongese imaginary : 30's Shanghai with all its heroes and its betrayers, cultural and historical crossroad.

Ding-Lik (Andy Lau) is a young boss of poor areas in Shanghai, limited to garbage man jobs, who falls in love with the daughter of a big shot of the town. Besides, Cheung Man-Kit (Leslie Cheung), memebre of the guomintang (taïwanes nationalist party) captured by the japanese, escapes and head for Shanghai. Both destiny meets and together, they conquer Shanghai underworld.

The movie, adapted from a major tv series, doesn't come without a side long saga too quicly related, but that probably is the main defect of the movie. Shanghai Grand on the other hand, does have a neat grooming on a photography and direction side as on a costumes and sceneries one. The movie contrasts a romance quite light and naive with another much more wild and rough. Man-Kit (Leslie Cheung), a revolutionnary bighearted Thereby, it's the whole film who skillfully mix lightness and viloence which gives some very interesting scenes.

Such actors encounter is quite rare on screen and that oneenlight the movie with an impressive aura. Leslie Cheung imposes his violent playing that we know of him while Andy Lau allows himself a few whimsy which he'll fully let go a few years later in other movies where he'll confirm what Shanghai Grand makes us suspect : Andy Lau is (learned to become) a great actor.

The direction is amitious but efficient with wide and graceful crane shots and several gunfights pretty stylish (the shot when Leslie pull out a gun from his corduroy (heavy velvet) jacket became mythic) and give to the film a interesting rythm even though a bit disturbed by a narration that Tarantino would surely love....not me...Ding Lik (Andy Lau), an ambitious young man...The musical theme has just become cult ever since, mostly for the sung version by Andy, and accompanies for the best this great saga. Costumes and sceneries have a large part in this magnificent historical reconstitution result and constitute of the great qualities of the movie.

In Brief, this mob saga on a historical background quite successful is one of the great film of HK 90's cinema and allows an encounter of two giants of Hong-Kong acting world, for our greatest pleasure. Shanghai Grand is an excellent movie that I much advise you to watch.



29 September 2005
by Archibald


buy it
info
actions
plus